Madden 25 Overall Review Guide
On August 16, 2024, EA released Madden 25, a simulation of the NFL, the only game of its kind on the market. Although the Madden series has released new games every year, this year’s Madden 25 is particularly noteworthy. This is not only because it is the 25th anniversary edition of the series, but also because it was released after the highly anticipated College Football 25, which sold very well.
Although the Madden series has performed mediocrely and public opinion has gradually declined over the past decade, this year’s release is expected to be a success. Will it change the tired situation of the series?
According to the reviews, the performance of Madden 25 is indeed divisive. On Metacritic, the game has a critic score of 80 points, while the user score is 56 points. This phenomenon reflects the tradition of the series, that is, professional reviewers give high scores, while players are relatively dissatisfied.
In recent years, the Madden series has been criticized frequently, with critics and users generally believing that these games have not made substantial progress year after year. The development team faces extremely tight development cycles, which has also resulted in each year’s version of the game looking like a simple update and lacking innovation.
The Recent History of Madden Games, According to Reviews
Recent entries have been far from beloved
More recently, though, the Maddenseries has become something of a laughingstock in the gaming sphere. Recent iterations of the game often receive poor reviews even from professional outlets, with most citing the game’s copy-and-paste feel from year to year.
How is Madden 25 doing? While College Football 25 was highly praised by critics, with a critic score of 84 and a user score of 5.6, Madden 25’s performance was disappointing. On Metacritic, the game has a critic score of 68 and a user score of only 3.1.
Brian Mazique of Forbes gave Madden 25 a high rating, believing that it is the most complete work in the series in many years, and praised the game’s improvements and customization features. However, Alex Raisbeck of VideoGamer gave it a low score of 40, criticizing the game’s lack of creativity and failure to keep up with the innovation of College Football 25.
“Madden 25 is the most complete version of the series in more than a decade. Failing to recognize the improvements essentially gives in to reflex hate more than evaluating each version’s merits. The gameplay is tighter, customization has seen a significant boost, and each mode has depth. If you buy a version of Madden every five years, it should be this one.”
On the other hand, Alex Raisbeck of VideoGamer eviscerated EA’s latest pro football effort, giving the game a mere 40/100. In his review, Alex blasts the game for feeling soulless, comparing it to the vastly more enjoyable and “obvious passion project” that is College Football 25:
“Madden 25 is the latest game in a series that appears to have either run out of ideas or simply has no interest in coming up with new ones. Small new additions do little to inspire excitement and a major overhaul feels desperately needed, and is the least that fans deserve. [These] issues have only become more apparent with the release of College Football 25.”
Summary
In a word, the reviews of Madden 25 are quite divided. Although some reviews believe that the game has improved, overall, user reviews are low and it has failed to significantly break through the traditional flaws of the series. If you are interested in the Madden series, you can consider buying it, but don’t expect it to completely change the tired state of the series.
In general, Madden 25 is generally mediocre because it adds new gameplay, franchise and superstar modes to give the Madden series a new look. No game is 100% perfect! Comments are comments, and there are a thousand Harry Potters for a thousand readers. For players who are quickly building and growing a Madden 25 team, you can consider to buy MUT 25 coins. I highly recommend U4GM, which has been committed to selling Madden coins, fast shipping and 100% legal operations. I also know the special discount code “cy2024”, which can enjoy a 5% discount when buying Madden 25 coins, which is very cost-effective!
